Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Tragedy at Frisco Track Meet: Karmelo Anthony Stabs Austin Metcalf – What We Know
⚖️ Tragedy at Frisco Track Meet: Stabbing, School Response, and Legal Fallout
A tragic incident at a Frisco, Texas high school track meet has gripped the nation, raising serious questions about school policies , juvenile justice , and social media responses . The case involves Karmelo Anthony , a 17-year-old accused of fatally stabbing fellow student Austin Metcalf during a confrontation over seating.
Since the April 2025 incident, the story has taken several dramatic turns — from public outrage over the accused teen’s graduation , to a controversial GoFundMe campaign , and ongoing legal proceedings that could determine whether Karmelo is tried as an adult for first-degree murder.
Let’s take a closer look at what we know so far.
📍 What Happened at the Track Meet?
The deadly confrontation occurred during a track meet at a school neither boy attended , where tensions escalated between two students:
- Austin Metcalf , 17, was a promising athlete and student set to graduate in 2026.
- Karmelo Anthony , also 17, was known for his academic achievements with a 3.7 GPA and had earned enough credits to graduate before the incident.
According to reports:
- The dispute began when Metcalf asked Anthony to move from a seat.
- Anthony reportedly warned him not to touch him, then allegedly pulled out a knife and stabbed Metcalf in the chest.
- Despite calling 911 and remaining at the scene, Anthony later claimed self-defense .
Metcalf died shortly after the attack. His family and supporters continue to mourn the loss of a young man described as “bright, kind, and full of potential.”
🎓 Controversy Over Graduation
One of the most controversial aspects of the case is the Frisco Independent School District’s decision to allow Karmelo Anthony to graduate while facing murder charges.
Sources indicate that Anthony’s graduation was part of an “agreement” made by the district — a claim that has drawn sharp criticism from Austin Metcalf’s father, Jeff Metcalf , who questions how the accused killer was allowed to walk at graduation while they were left to bury their son.
Meanwhile, an online petition demanding Austin be awarded an honorary diploma has gathered over 15,000 signatures , reflecting public sympathy for the victim’s family.
💰 Viral Fundraising Effort Sparks Outrage
In the wake of the tragedy, a GoFundMe page surfaced claiming to raise money for Karmelo Anthony’s legal defense. The fundraiser quickly surpassed $500,000 , drawing national attention — and backlash.
However, Anthony’s parents publicly denounced the campaign , stating it was not started by them and accusing it of spreading misinformation. They also revealed receiving threats linked to the case.
This has raised concerns about how online fundraising platforms are being used in sensitive criminal cases, especially those involving minors.
🧾 Court Developments and Legal Concerns
Karmelo Anthony is currently charged with first-degree murder under Texas’ concurrent jurisdiction laws , which allow prosecutors to try minors as adults without judicial oversight .
Key legal facts include:
Under Texas law, if convicted as an adult, Anthony — now 17 — would be eligible for parole after 40 years .
His case has reignited debates over racial disparities in juvenile sentencing and calls for reforming direct-file laws , which disproportionately affect Black and Latino youth .
🗣️ Community Reactions and Public Backlash
The case has sparked intense debate across social media and in the local community:
- Many have criticized the decision to allow Anthony to graduate amid a pending murder charge.
- Others have condemned the bail reduction granted by Judge Angela Tucker — who is Black — prompting threats against her safety .
- Some have questioned why the school district did not intervene or prevent such a violent confrontation at a school event.
Jeff Metcalf, Austin’s father, was seen confronting officials at a press conference but left after speaking with police — underscoring the emotional toll on both families.
